Why Some Martial Artists Fail to Finish The Job | martial arts management
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
When I created NAPMA, the ACMA, and the Martial Arts Teachers Association, I took tremendous heat for helping schools to create programs and systems that would help them reach more people through the martial arts. Today, these systems and organizations are common within the professional martial arts business and, in fact, pretty much taken for granted. I’m proud of these contributions, but as I think about the journey I can’t help but reflect on how confusing the process of change within a field as traditional as the martial arts can be.
The confusion about change is not restricted just to the business or sport, but it drills down to the very essence of the change we all undergo as we progress through the ranks and, for some of us, decide this is our life’s calling.
Gichin Funakoshi, the father of Japanese karate, is renowned – and deservedly so – for making massive changes to Okinawan karate so it would be more acceptable to the Japanese. We have great systems like Shotokan today as a direct result of his efforts.
But isn’t changing a style to be accepted on a wider scale the ultimate in commercialization of the arts? Funakoshi had a deep understanding of the system, and he questioned everything. He made changes and found his own voice, and it’s a voice that echoes throughout the martial arts world to this day.
Jigoro Kano stripped the deadly techniques from jujitsu and created judo. He founded Kodokan judo at age 22! He is also the creator of the colored belt system, which his friend Gichin Funakoshi adapted for karate. How would you respond today if a 22 year old told you he was changing your system and creating a new one? Most of us would think, who the heck are you to change this style?
Both of these martial arts heroes had the courage to question and innovate. Yet many of their descendants are passionate that the systems these men created should never change. It’s as though the styles froze with their founders’ passing.
Joe Lewis pays tremendous homage to his instructors, yet he has his own identity. He took his theories and ideas and battle-tested them in the ring and is still innovating to this day. In 30+ years of working with world-caliber martial artists, I have yet to see an instructor who even comes close to him. He lives, eats, and breathes martial arts. Bill Wallace is a good friend of mine who is also proud of his Okinawan roots, but he certainly has his own voice. Like Lewis, his voice is totally different than his instructors.
No unique voice in the martial arts has had the long-term impact of Bruce Lee. His instructor was Yip Man, but he was clear in his pursuit of truth in the martial arts and knew it could not be found in the confines of any style or label. Lee said that the martial arts are about honestly expressing yourself, and I totally agree. However, I don’t see that a lot. I see a lot of robot-like mimicking and cloning. I see young instructors trying to call themselves Master so they gain the respect for the implied wisdom that comes with that title long before gaining the experience that creates it.
Finding your own voice or identity as a martial artist is the opposite. It’s creating a martial arts school that authentically reflects you as a growing martial artist and as a human being, rather than quickly creating the illusion that you have already taken the journey and are already on the other side as a Master. It’s about surpassing your instructors in every way and being proud of it, rather than ashamed.
Today, in addition to the implied wisdom of positioning yourself like a Master Po from the Kung Fu TV series, we have the martial arts millionaire syndrome. Consultants who present the image that they have become millionaires as a result of a career in the martial arts industry and, if you do what they do, you can become one too. It can happen, but you want to make sure it’s really the lifestyle you want.
I have a consulting client who has been very successful. He has one school, and it profits him $250,000 annually, but he wants four schools. Why? Because he took a martial arts business seminar, and the speaker said the way to wealth is multiple stores (yes, he even called them stores). My client has now opened another black belt school and it is not only sucking him dry, but it is creating huge stress on his family. The same thing happened to me that is happening to him. We both went from being a martial arts instructor doing what we loved; teaching, to being a multiple location business manager doing what we hated; business.
I asked him why he got into teaching martial arts at all. He said he likes to help people and it’s a good quality of life. Well, his quality of life has gone from good to bad quickly. He has lost touch with his original goals of teaching for a living. Even his big income is threatened, because he got excited about achieving someone else’s goal. The seminar leader had goals of making millions, not quality of life. My client got caught up in it and allowed his own goals to be replaced by the seminar leader’s goals. He found the seminar leader’s voice, not his. This is a business example, but we often see a similar situation when a black belt remains in the shadow of his master for his entire career.
The martial arts is about improving yourself as a person. Many of us use it to create a new identity and that’s fine, but it’s only part of the journey. The real goal is to come out the other side as the authentic you who uses martial arts as one way of expressing yourself. Many martial artists fail to complete this metamorphosis and stop at making the martial arts their entire identity rather than simply an extension of who they are.












I personally am having a hard time myself starting though I have much knowledge its mainly become a game of who can market quicker or has the money to just poof two or more studios at once. Though I am more traditional then most new age stuff out here I really find it hard on breaking my own beliefs and what I was taught just to go with the new trend. I still make you hurt and I dont care because thats Martial Arts! One day everyone will realize that theese new age crap styles are just too much they are at a point where 3-5 years for your 1st degree black belt but that is just a money stradegy and not anything more they suck there students in for that long and what have you gained? not much I think its better to end sooner because you will always want fresh students and teachers. I am sorry for going off but the new trend is sux!